Bartleby the Scrivener

"I would prefer not to." - Herman Melville.

This short story was so annoying! Sorry Mr. Costello, but you got my hopes up when you showed us the video of Bartleby.  I thought this short story was going to be really funny but it just turned out to be super irritating.  No hard feelings, though.  Anyway, the quote above is the quote Bartleby said everytime he was asked to do something he really didn't feel like doing.  The one coincidence I found in the story was that Bartleby seemed just fine doing all these basic tasks until he was asked to do them by someone (For instance, he stops eating while in prison.).  As soon as he was asked to do those tasks, he refused.  Maybe he felt he was going to become subordinate to that person or something.  In the end, Bartleby died.  Perhaps he was asked to do all the necessary activites of life and after refusing to do those, he was unable to live. 

Hunters In The Snow

"'You fat moron,' Frank said.  'You aren't good for diddly.'" - Tobias Wolff.

For this blog, I am going to formally answer a question included in the text book.  The question is this:

Which of the three principal characters do you find most sympathetic?  The least sympathetic?  Discuss your answers.  do the characters' names help us to form our impression of them?

The character I find most sympathetic is without a doubt, Tub.  He is always being picked on as the quote I used above shows.  Kenny and Frank always seem to be ganging up on him and making fun of him.  For example, they almost ran over him with the truck at the very beginning of the story.  When Tub tells them they could have killed him they sort of just laughted and said they were kidding around, not taking the situation very seriously.  They also just leave him by himself in the snow as they are walking back to the truck.  No wonder he is eating himself to death.  His feelings are always low because his friends treat him porely and the only way to make himself feel better is by eating.  The character I find the least sympathetic is Kenny.  He is the one who was mostly instigating the teasing.  He even went as far as saying he hated Tub and pretending he was going to shoot him.  I hate to say it, but it's almost like he got what he deserved when Tub reacted by shooting him in the gut.  Obviously he doesn't deserve to die but he was just asking for Tub to shoot him.  As for the names of the characters, I believe Tub's name is the most obvious for creating an impression in my mind.  The name Tub just makes me think of a short, fat man.  This description is very similar to the one given in the book.  As for the other two, my impression from their names are probably a bit of a long shot.  The name Frank seems like an older, wiser name.  Frank can therefore be identified as the one who is more grown up and who has a dramatic change of heart in this short story.  The name Kenny makes me think of a playful person.  I also think of a jokester.  This also is similar to the description given in the book.

Everyday Use

"When I looked at her like that something hit me in the top of my head and ran down to the soles of my feet." - Alice Walker.

For this blog I am going to formally answer a question included in the text book.  The question is this:

Does the mother's refusal to let Dee have the quilts indicate a permanent or temporary change of character?  Why has she never done anything like it before?  Why does she do it now?  What details in the story prepare for and foreshadow that refusal?

I believe the mother's refusal to let Dee have the quilts indicates a permanent change in character.  Like the quote I used above says, "something hit [her] in the top of [her] head and ran down the soles of [her] feet."  This wasn't just a random feeling of sympathy she had for Maggie.  It was like suddenly she realized that she had to let Maggie win this one thing.  Forever, now, the mother will let Maggie have more over her sister because she realized that she too deserves to have what her sister has.  The reason her mother has never done anything like this before is because it has never hit her upon her head before.  She relates it to when she is in church and suddenly the spirit touches her and she gets happy and shouts.  It was random and sort of came out of the blue.  One detail in the story that foreshadows that refusal is at the very beginning when the mother says, "You've no doubt seen those TV shows where the child who has 'made it' is confronted, as a surprise, by her own mother and father, tottering in weakly from backstage."  I didn't realized until later that the mother was talking about confronting, standing up to, and refusing to give the quilts to her daughter, Dee.

A Rose For Emily - Blog #2

"Miss Emily met them at the door, dressed as usual and with no trace of grief on her face.  She told them that her father was not dead.  She did that for three days, with the ministers calling on her, and the doctors, trying to persuade her to let them dispose of the body." - William Faulkner.

The biggest question I had at the end of this short story was why on earth Miss Emily would kill Homer Barron, keep him in her house, and sleep with him at night.  I think the answer lies within the story itself.  The one example and reasoning I could find was in the quote above.  After her father died, Miss Emily had a hard time coping with the fact that she was all alone.  This shows that she has problems letting go of things.  When Homer Barron didn't want to marry her and was about to leave her, she probably freaked, not wanting to let go and be alone again.  She then resorted to killing the man.  As I stated in the previous blog, I felt bad for her throughout the entire story.  I have no idea what it would be like to be completely alone and so I felt sypathetic for her.  Once I found out that she killed the man, I lost all sympathy.

A Rose For Emily

"The man himself lay in the bed...One of us lifted something from it, and leaning forward, that faint and invisible dust dry and acrid in the nostrils, we saw a long strand of iron-gray hair." - William Faulkner.


For this blog, I am going to formally answer a question included in the text book.  The question is this:

What is the effect of the final paragraph?  How does it change the reader's attitude toward Emily and her fate?

The effect of the final paragraph was to create shock and surprise.  I was totally caught off guard when I read it.  Once I did read it, though, I realized how all the pieces fit together.  The poison she bought was probably used to kill the man.  The smell that so many of the towns people were complaining about was probably the smell of the decaying body.  My attitude, as well as the attitude of probably almost every reader, was definitely changed by the final paragraph.  Through the course of the story, I felt sort of bad for the woman.  She seemed to be living a sad life where everyone around her was dying.  She seemed lonely and unhappy the entire time.  After reading the last paragraph, I was disgusted by Miss Emily.  I now saw her as a psychotic, crazed woman who was obsessed with having a man stay with her.

Interpreter of Maladies

"When she whipped out the hairbrush, the slip of paper with Mr. Kapasi's address on it fluttered away into the wind." - Jhumpa Lahiri.

Throughout this short story, I felt sort of sympathetic for Mr. Kapasi.  He talked of how he knew all these different languages.  This made me feel like he had such great opportunities and was going to be able to go places in the world.  Yet, he only ended up being a tour guide, driving tourists like annoying Americans all about India.  The point of the story was that while invisioning writing Mrs. Das, Mr. Kapasi remembered how he felt after being able to understand a writing of some different language.  The sad part is that in the quote above, Mr. Kapasi sees his dreams and rememberences flutter away with the paper as it leaves Mrs. Das's bag.  It is just really sad that the most he is able to do with his life is deal with tourists and possible listen to their problems like how he listened to Mrs. Das's problems.  The fact that Mr. Kapasi just watched the paper fly away instead of saying something to Mrs. Das shows that he did not feel comfortable in the end engaging with Mrs. Das through letters after hearing her story and problems.  Maybe this was him giving up on his dreams altogether.

How I Met My Husband

"So I said yes, and I went out with him for two years and he asked me to marry him, and we were engaged a year more while I got my things together, and then we did marry." - Alice Munro.

For this blog entry, I am going to formally answer a question included in the text book.  The question is this:

Describe the plot structure in the story.  How is the arrangement of the plot elements effective?  At which points were your expectations as a reader overturned?

The plot of the story is told in chronological order, starting from what happened first and ending with what happened last.  Throughout the entire story, though, I thought the man Edie was going to marry was the pilot, Chris.  It wasn't untill literally the last paragraph of the entire short story that I found out that it was actually the mailman who she ended up marrying.  That last paragraph was when my expectations were overturned.  I thought it was ironic how Edie never out told what the mailman's name was yet we knew the pilot's name was Chris.  I sort of feel like Edie still had feelings for Chris even as she was married to the mailman for this specific reason.  But now I am getting a little off topic.  The arrangement of the plot elements is effective because it helps to explain just what the title says, how she met her husband.  It was in falling for the pilot that led her to her husband.  The reader needed to know these key details becuase it was the only way for us to understand how Edie came about waiting everyday by the mailbox for that letter and getting to know the mailman.